QUOTE (Karl187 @ Aug 14 2009, 01:20 PM)

For a start Jax, an internet forum is the L-A-S-T place I would go for advice on medical issues. I would consult a doctor or nurse, i.e. experts with medical qualifications- not someone on an internet forum who could pretty much be anyone in the world. I was told in hospital to check these kinds of forums to see what e-x-p-e-r-i-e-n-c-e-s people had of the issues at hand, not to get expert medical advice. Anyone seeking that here really needs to assess their line of thinking.
I'm also not making light of pomerv's situation- I've been in a similar situation, funnily enough. I was making light of your attitude which was heavier than most doctors, especially for someone who is not a doctor or medical professional.
I do consulting work at Queen's University Belfast School of Nursing and Midwifery and I assisst in the structure of post-graduate modules within the field of specialist practice, pain management, patient services and fracture trauma. I also guest lecture in these areas as an 'end-user' of NHS services. My input is nothing more than the sum of my e-x-p-e-r-i-e-n-c-e. (There's that word again...). This is also mostly unpaid consultancy (except for some fees for guest lecture spots) as I am not a medical professional and, let me re-iterate strong, neither are you. So I made an error in not understanding the full idea of a flaccid bowel and perhaps offered less than sage advice- but of course, we're now back to my original point: If you have a medical query then seek the help of a MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL, not an internet forum. This, Jax, is the best advice I, or you, could ever offer to pomerv and I suspect that he himself knew this before he even started this thread.
First, a bit for pomerv.
"Eventually you won't need these strong medications and that will help your bowels."-This is only partly true. It will help them to empty more frequently, if the problem is lack of function in the
upper part of the colon. If the problem is that the bowels are emptying too often already (which indicates flaccid sphincter, and at least some upper colon function), then the lack of those medications could actually make the accidents happen more frequently.
"High fibre things like All-Bran, wheat cereals and certain types of fruit will help." High-fiber foods will not necessarily help. With flaccid bowel, consuming high-fiber foods can actually increase the frequency of accidents. Again, the effect is partly dependent upon how much function is present in the upper part of the colon versus the amount of tension present in the sphincter.
"Some medicines like Lactulose, which they seem to use a lot in hospitals, may actually work against you." This is definitely a good piece of advice. The
lactulose can have a very negative effect for people with flaccid bowel. Lactulose, like many other products meant to promote water intake to the bowels can cause dehydration if overused or used when one is not constipated. It will also generally cause more bowel accidents in those with flaccid bowel.
Karl,
You made no error in not understanding the full idea of a flaccid bowel, but rather in offering advice without that understanding. There are plenty of doctors, nurses, and OTAs (
all medical professionals) that do the same thing every day. "Less than sage advice?" You had one point about lactulose that was a good warning. Just wish you made a point of how bad the lactulose effects could be. Most of the rest of your original response was all about your reflex bowel experience and contained nothing useful for someone with flaccid bowel.
"So- experiment and it'll come in the end." WTF kind of advice is this? It is obvious that pomerv knows it will come out. It already comes out too much and likely too often.
From what I read on the Queen's University School of Nursing and Midwifery website, it seems that SCI bowel issues are not even part of the focus of the postgraduate program. Nursing and midwifery? Wow. Nursing barely even scratches the surface of a select few issues related to SCI. (My wife just completed her RN. I can give you the names of the books they used if you would like to see how uninformative they are to the nurses when it comes to SCI.) Midwifery has how much to do with non-pediatric SCI bowel issues? Unless you're birthing mothers with SCIs every day, I'd say not very much.
Assist in the structure of post-graduate modules within the field of specialist practice? What kind of assistance do you give to the structure of those modules? You're rather vague here, and sound a bit like a lawyer or politician trying to slip one past by using your colorful description as a distraction. What all specialist fields are included? From the information provided on the website for the QUB NMRU post-graduate research program, I have found no mention of SCI. "Investigating aspects of health and health care related to high risk pregnancy, childbirth and babies born requiring neonatal intensive care as well as children surviving with neurological impairments or cerebral palsy" is about as close as it gets. All of that revolves around babies. Where do non-pediatric SCI issues fit in there? There are 2 focal topics of research shown for the post-graduate research program. They are: 1-Maternal and Child Health; 2-Evaluation of Complex Healthcare Interventions. Is there even a SCI topic in their research?
Patient services? Sounds like a hospital version of a concierge.
Fracture trauma? That's ortho, not colon-rectal, and not OT for SCI. The cord and the vertebrae can be damaged independently, you know....
I see you must have not had the great experience of dealing with uninformative, inexperienced, or just plain quack "medical professionals." I have. As a matter of fact, you talk a lot about your
experience, but I don't see how any of the experience you say you have pertains to flaccid bowels in persons with SCI.
This forum
was the last place
I looked! (Sorry, Simon) Logic, along with my personal experience (and several of the experiences I've read about on here), makes me think there is a pretty good chance that, since pomerv was still in hospital when posting this, there was not much (or at least not enough) help given by the types of medical professionals that you say to consult. That lack of help and information from medical professionals is what turned me to the internet to learn for myself. Until I read a lot of stuff on this forum a couple yrs ago, I didn't know just how bad the advice I got (over the 8 months or so prior to that) from those certain "medical professionals" had been. So far, this forum has proven over and over to me to have information available that is worth so much more than anyone could ever truly understand. It took me a bit to figure out which information was coming from somebody with certain issues similar to mine, but I did. That makes a lot of difference, too. I'm just trying to make it easier for someone else to distinguish.
Of course my attitude is going to be "heavier" than most doctors and other medical professionals. That is because most "medical professionals" don't really know very much about the specifics of flaccid bowels. I've asked quite a few, and so far, the majority of ones I've asked don't really know much. I keep getting the answer of "Try to make your bowels move at the same time every day." Anyone with flaccid bowel knows that advice is useless. The lack of "medical professionals" who are experienced in dealing with SCI is quite astonishing here in America, as well as other places I would figure. What makes you think there are no medical professionals online? There is at least 1 other forum online that is actually associated with Rutgers University. I'm not fond of some of the members, but here is the
link so you can check it out for yourself. I know that discerning who is truly a medical professional is difficult sometimes, but (I would figure) many of us here are pretty good at being able to tell the difference. (I'm pretty sure Simon is rather adept at making the distinction.) Maybe distinguishing quacks from those who are knowledgeable and experienced is a difficult task as well, but that's generally the case offline, too. I've been there.
You get paid to guest lecture about the NHS? From the website of the QUB NMRU, I see that the "Evaluation of Complex Healthcare Interventions" is described as "investigating the translation of complex healthcare interventions into practice and their sustainability using mixed research methods." That's interesting. So, does a lot of your work involve researching how (and how well) healthcare intervention "theories" translate into their "applications?" If so, I would think that you would know better than many that something may sound wonderful in theory, but it could still be unused/unusable/misused/unsuccessful in application. That's what I'm talking about when I say that doctors don't know much about things like SCI bowel problems. The theory you are working with is that they all should, but in actuality, not all do. If they all did, I'll bet there would be a lot less people on this forum (and others) asking questions like pomerv's.
Since many doctors are not experienced in working with patients with SCI (as we are in quite the minority), many of the treatments/equipment we may need (or be able to use) have not been done/used by very many doctors to treat/help SCI issues. Many doctors may not even have
considered that certain treatments/equipment could be used for SCI issues. I have read other posts on here where other forum members have heard similar things from their doctors. So the "ask a doctor" argument doesn't hold up.
Here's some personal experience for you.
I married a nurse that worked in the rehab wing of Scott & White Hospital (one of the larger hospital chains here in TX), and neither she nor her nurse coworkers had any knowledge of the treatments for flaccid bowel when I was in rehab. I've asked them. You can ask, too, if you like. Call Scott and White Hospital, Temple, Texas. Ask for any nurse on STC4. You could even call their OT department and ask for Lauren, or call the Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation department and ask for Dr. John Schuchmann. I'll bet you get transferred at least 3 times before you find someone who will even address what a flaccid bowel is. That is if you don't get transferred to somebody's voicemail every time you call. Dr. James Albers would be about the only one with a clue. See if the others don't try to tell you some BS about how you should use suppositories for flaccid bowel. It's contradictory to the intended use of the suppositories that's written on the freaking box. If I could read the box and know better than to use those things for flaccid bowel, why couldn't those "medical professionals?"
I went to 5 different "Physical Medicine and Rehabilitation" doctors, 3 different OTs, several colon-rectal surgeons, and 2 different urologists trying to get the flaccid bowel and bladder sphincter issues figured out. I drove several trips each to Houston (Evaluation at TIRR), Temple (urologist), Ft. Worth (urologist), and Austin (colon-rectal surgeons) from the town in which I lived 2 yrs ago. No solutions came. After reading through a lot of posts on this site, I found a mentioning of the AUS. I looked it up on the web, and asked a urologist about it. Although he hadn't previously done the AUS procedure on anyone as young as I was, he still installed an AUS in me.
Finding a doctor with good knowledge and experience in the field of SCI bowel issues is very difficult if you don't meet one while you are in rehab, incidentally know somebody that knows one, or just get really lucky in the search. At least, that's the case in a good portion of TX. After a couple of colon-rectal surgeons I visited showed me they knew nothing about SCI bowel issues at all, I had to find my own doc. I got a referral from my wife's primary care doctor to a gastroenterologist. That gastroenterologist sent me to another colon-rectal surgeon. His specialty was colostomies in patients with colon cancer, so he wasn't any real help. I got tired of the run-around, driving all the time, and lack of progress, so I called more than 30 colon-rectal surgeons to see what experience each had with SCI bowel treatment. Apparently, many colon-rectal surgeons are really nothing more than colostomy doctors. 1 colon-rectal surgeon actually told me a colostomy was my only option before I even told him what all I had tried already. All I told him was that I had a flaccid bowel due to SCI, and he immediately came out with "A colostomy would be your best option, and really the only option here." One actually told me that if I wanted something to help my bowels, but didn't want a colostomy, I was "asking for a miracle, and we don't work miracles." A colostomy is
not only option, I have since learned. For that matter, it's not even close to the best option for me. What good does it do to go to "medical professionals" who are themselves inexperienced and uninformed? If I had listened to those "medical professionals," I would now be living with a colostomy and the knowledge that it was unnecessary. Good thing I looked on this internet forum. Now, I have found some options, and presented them to a colon-rectal surgeon. He agrees that the ACE is a good option for me, and I'm waiting to have it done.
"Unpaid consultancy?" That sounds remarkably similar to what is done by almost anybody who posts any kind of advice on a forum, no matter what experience the person may or may not have regarding the particular topic. Does your definition of "unpaid consultancy" mean "volunteer" work? Generally, volunteer work is to be respected. As I have said before, I have been volunteering since last December at a SCI rehab center. I have learned a lot over these months, and I have recently been offered a paying job (which I am accepting) as a therapy assistant. So, I have actually done work (and soon will be paid for doing that work) directly with people with SCIs, helping them with SCI issues. Does your work involve dealing with SCI issues? You go feed someone else your "let me re-iterate strong." Although I'm at the bottom of therapy for now, I am at least working and studying to become a "medical professional." (Who knows, maybe I'll even get a PhD. After all, it is one of my little goals.) The issue of flaccid bowel is part of not only my area of study, but also my
life (especially considering I actually have flaccid bowel). Since having all my issues dealing with so-called "medical professionals" post-SCI, I have dedicated my studies and life to helping people with SCI through occupational therapy and better, more available information regarding SCI and SCI issues. (Those are the big goals. Too bad Simon beat me to starting a good forum for the second big one. Now I have to find a different way.)