reallynewatthis, on Nov 23 2009, 06:10 PM, said:
The DNR was from his personal advance directive. Right now our number one concern is pneumonia,
My name is Terri and I look forward to being able to get to know all of you for a good long time.
Hi Terri,
What I am getting at, with regards to the DNR, is that at this point, DNR is no longer an idea or a concept just "out there". Your guy is very close to death. But he has the chance to make a complete recovery (as an sci of course). So the question is: Does he want to risk that recovery, by instructing doctors to let him go, should he experience one critical moment of failure?
I ask this, because I know what I am talking about. I could have been dead. If I had let the wrong instructions I would be dead. And now, thirty years later I am very much alive.
allis53ca has responded to my post:
Quote
the entire point of having a DNR, is to have control of what happens to us in these situations...you're encouraging others to ignore someones life wishes..not cool
I do not want the patient's wishes to be ignored. But I think that if he is lucid, you should ask him to consider changing his instructions. Because, as I said, this is no longer a concept situation, this is real. As any sci can tell you, able-bodied people say all kinds of nonsense, such as, "I could never live like that!". And guess what, when it DOES happen, people DO live with it.
Similarly, "I would not want to live on a resperator!" , Why not?
Or, "If I am dying anyway I don't want them to bring me back" Oh, Yeah?
The fact is, people make these statements when they have no idea of what they are talking about. And they can easily sign off an a DNR that will needlessly cost them a long life.
So, IF he says he is ready to survive this accident, then IF we wants to be SURE he gets the chance (particularly once they get him on the operating table), THEN, he had better think NOW of putting his DNR on hold. ANd he had better do it very thourougly, because even a little paper sticker on an old medical chart on an inside page could do the dirty when the time comes.
(allis53ca: What I want is for this particular person to understand that DNR is not, in the present case, about some eventuality and his own right to choose for himself. THis is about survival RIGHT NOW. And when the case is put to them that way, it is my experience that people change their minds about DNR)
Quote
he is extremely susceptible to lung infections and already spiked a very high fever and had his lungs fill with fluid. However, the antibiotics seem to be digging in and he doing a little better.
Also, I talked to his doctor and he is a T-8. Primary concern is going to be his ability to cough and keep his lungs clear.
This is exactly the same for me, and for most of us, and it is worse with higher lesions. Many will remain ventilated throught their whole lives.
In my case, I survived the repair, and thought I was out of the woods, but nearly died about a month later from infection from my collapsed lung. Suction every fifteen minutes or so, to enable me to breath. This too, will pass. This too is something that you should ask your doctors to do EVERYTHING to get you through it, not to give them an excuse to just stand back and let you drown.
But this is just my opinion. I love life. I do not think there is a life "not worth living". A the very least, I think you should tlak to him about the possibility of getting through the NOW to the AFTERWARDS, and that that proccess may include some very agressive medicine.
Bottom line:Does he want to live?
If so, what in the dickens is doing with a DNR on his chart?
Best Regards,
Gordon